2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Ratings discussion in here
User avatar
JBIsles
NY Isles GM
Posts: 71
Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2022 6:04 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by JBIsles »

Justin Danforth (Rookie)
DF Rating 35 - Requested DF 60

He played well in a fourth line role and doesn't deserve anywhere near the worst DF in the league, especially getting pk time.

Danforth’s speed, tenacity, and willingness to play in the dirty areas proved valuable for the Blue Jackets this season....He added value by playing hard and contributing defensively
https://www.jacketscannon.com/2022/6/3/ ... e-paid-off

He’s a penalty-killer, he’s a power-play guy and plays in all situations, he’s basically been the total package.”
https://www.dispatch.com/story/sports/n ... 344455001/

I would expect Danforth to play on one of the team’s penalty kill units and bring that same speed and tenacity to help the team in those situations...Basically, he just needs to stay healthy and bring his game from last season.
https://unionandblue.com/2022/09/12/202 ... -danforth/

Putting Justin Danforth opposite means you add speed and a touch of skill to this unit. Danforth is a hockey veteran whose motor turns all the time – I could see him emerging as a terrific penalty killer
https://unionandblue.com/2022/09/22/pre ... s-units/2/
Image
User avatar
JBIsles
NY Isles GM
Posts: 71
Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2022 6:04 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by JBIsles »

Conor Sheary (2nd challenge from Dallas)
DF Rating 44 - Requested DF 60

Sheary has shown to be a solid player at both ends of the ice and deserves a much higher rating than a 44.

The 29-year-old also played well at the other end of the ice. He took great care of the puck and played an efficient two-way game that helped him maintain possession and move the puck up ice. Sheary boasted 2.06 takeaways per game, the highest of his career,
https://washingtonhockeynow.com/washing ... d-2021-22/
Sheary is a dependable two-way forward
https://www.si.com/nhl/2018/06/27/conor ... de-hunwick

while establishing himself as a player available to Head Coach Peter Laviolette in just about any situation...and ranks fifth in takeaways.
https://novacapsfans.com/2022/03/06/mr- ... ls-lineup/
However, Sheary might be one of the Sabres' better two-way players...."I think he’s good all over the ice," Mittelstadt said of Sheary. "He’s such a good forechecker. He’s so fast. He’s always going in there and taking pucks, protecting pucks. He does a good job."
https://buffalonews.com/sports/sabres/s ... e8542.html

The 30-year-old can play any role for the Capitals, is cheap, and can produce. Those players are hard to find.
https://novacapsfans.com/2022/08/18/ext ... act-years/
Image
User avatar
JBIsles
NY Isles GM
Posts: 71
Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2022 6:04 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by JBIsles »

Tyler Motte (3rd challenge from Dallas)
DF Rating 65 - Requested DF 75

An excellent PK'er and defensive forward. Notice the chart below, for 21-22, his defensive rating shot up to 100%

Senators sign 'tenacious checker' Tyler Motte..."Tyler is a tenacious checker who plays the game with pace," Senators general manager Pierre Dorion said in a release. "He's a strong penalty killer and another competitive person who adds to the depth of our group."
https://www.cbc.ca/sports/hockey/nhl/nh ... -1.6582781

bringing in two-way energy forward Tyler Motte from the Vancouver Canucks....Motte showed through his complete game just how valuable he was to a team that was able to make a deeper playoff run than many had anticipated....Motte has made a career for himself out of being a high-energy and defensively reliable forward who can play in all situations. This season represented arguably his best...Where Motte becomes increasingly valuable is his ability to contribute on the penalty kill and to play in his own zone, which most notably includes a career 71% defensive zone starts percentage versus 29% in the offensive zone. In other words, Motte is capable and trusted to play important shifts of defensive hockey for his teams.
https://www.prohockeyrumors.com/2022/08 ... motte.html

Motte is one of the most underrated Canucks on the roster. He is an integral part of the Canucks penalty kill and the bottom six. TSN even gave him some love...Motte’s biggest strength is the penalty kill. He makes life difficult for the opposing team’s power play by tracking the puck and finding the right opportunity to steal it and clear it out....You can see a clip here of Motte on the penalty kill when he was with the Blackhawks. He makes similar plays with the Canucks As you can see, Motte tracks the puck and forced to turnover so his teammate can break the puck out and kill valuable time....The Canucks have already faced plenty of time on the penalty kill in the series against the Blues, and Motte is one of the reasons why they have been successful (mostly) against a very good power play.
Motte makes excellent reads, gets into the areas around the net to clear the puck away while making his physical presence known.
Motte also provides defence to the bottom six by blocking shots and breaking the puck out of the defensive zone (he blocked 37 shots this season).However, the penalty kill is where Motte really shines.
Motte is a big part of the Canucks penalty kill, and he’s a key reason why it’s been so successful. He works hard, provides speed and energy, and makes good reads so he can takeaway the puck.
https://thecanuckway.com/2020/08/17/can ... ttes-game/

Tyler Motte making great defensive plays? Shocking.

https://twitter.com/danriccio_/status/1 ... 3752089601 (Tweeted sarcastically as he is always making great defensive plays)

Tyler Motte, 27, was acquired at the March 21 trade deadline. He was primarily brought in to add speed and relentless forechecking to the fourth line. His ability to kill penalties was an added bonus....If he can suit up for another do-or-die game in this series it will be a huge boost to the Rangers checking line and PK unit. “His speed, his penalty killing, and he’s a defensive player,” Gallant said. “He’d definitely be a big help for our club [if he can play].”
https://www.foreverblueshirts.com/tyler ... -practice/

Motte is a pure defensive-forward with minimal play-making ability whose primary role is killing penalties and grinding down opposing defenses via forechecking....Ottawa needed to insulate their team defense, and Motte is a great insertion into the team's bottom-six to do so.
https://www.markerzone.com/news/index.php?no=156000

Image
Image
Ken - Ducks
Anaheim GM
Posts: 56
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 6:17 am

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by Ken - Ducks »

Alex Iafallo
DF 61 -> 73
SP 75 -> 78
SK 75 -> 78

From an article March 9, 2022 (and it isn't an LA homer take):
A relentless forward with elite defensive awareness...
Iafallo’s projected defensive wins above replacement – a metric that illustrates a player’s impact away from the puck in 5-on-5 situations – was tied with Patrice Bergeron and Marcus Foligno for first among all NHL forwards entering Saturday, according to Evolving-Hockey.com.
...he trails only Kopitar in short-handed ice time among Los Angeles forwards...
https://buffalonews.com/sports/sabres/e ... b6894.html

Alex was 2 takeaways short of Kopitar on the season while playing 2 less games and averaging over a 1:30 less EV TOI per game. For forwards with over 10 GP, he had the 2nd highest EV defensive zone starts (dZS%) on the team.

Only Kopitar (DF 77) and Danault (DF 72) averaged more SH TOI (only 0:04 more) than Iafallo among LA forwards.

As for speed...
Combined with his excellent support, positioning and detail, his speed and pacing aided his forechecking...
...suggesting an appropriate role in waiting as a responsible third-line winger who can contribute much-needed speed, pacing and secondary scoring...
https://lakingsinsider.com/2018/07/12/p ... n-iafallo/
As alluded to earlier, Iafallo isn’t s big guy, so he relies heavily on his speed, and that includes while he’s on the forecheck...
https://frozenroyalty.net/2017/12/17/alex-iafallo-line/


Erik Brannstrom
SP 73 -> 77
SK 71 -> 77

Brannstrom achieves a deep, 90-degree knee bend while keeping his back straight and torso over his feet for balance and muscle activation.
https://theathletic.com/870513/2019/03/ ... hockey-iq/
Brannstrom, the No. 15 pick in the 2017 NHL Draft, was lauded for his vision and speed playing against mostly older players with HV71 in Sweden last season.
https://www.nhl.com/news/vegas-golden-k ... -290522674
In order to succeed in the NHL as an undersized defenceman, one must be an excellent skater. Brannstrom certainly checks that box. He has outstanding speed in both directions and gets up to top speed quickly, with great acceleration. Brannstrom has an excellent stride, and his strong lower body gives him a lot of power. He is able to fight through checks, and is tough to knock off the puck. He also has very good edge work and agility. Brannstrom can use subtle moves and shifts to get past forecheckers and start the transition game.
https://lastwordonsports.com/hockey/201 ... -draft-30/


Trevor Moore
DF 58 -> 68
SP 73 -> 77
SK 69 -> 75

On a team with an identity of solid two-way play, Trevor Moore averaged over a minute of PK time per game (1:13). He had the highest CF%Rel on the PK for the Kings among skaters that played half the season, and notched 5 goals and 6 points while on the PK - tying for the league lead in both categories. He also finished 5th on the team in takeaways.

https://bleacherreport.com/articles/100 ... -23-season
...he knew how to create plays using those quick and agile edges, as well as his powerful and effective puck handling and movement skills.
https://hockeyroyalty.com/2022/04/25/la ... vor-moore/
His speed is his best asset, using that trait to get in position to score timely, important goals.
https://hockeyroyalty.com/2022/05/17/gr ... t-wingers/

Trevor was also voted the Best Defensive Player on the team by the media.

https://lakingsinsider.com/2022/04/30/l ... am-awards/


Cole Sillinger (rookie)
DF 37 -> 64
SP 72 -> 75
SK 74 -> 76

I pulled all forwards from https://www.hockey-reference.com/ for last season along with short-handed ice time. Then I matched to forwards in GVFHL. Here are the results:

All forwards with PK time - average defense in GVFHL: 55
All forwards with PK time - median defense in GVFHL: 59

When removing the noise of line changes:
Forwards with more than 10 seconds of PK time per game - average defense in GVFHL: 57
Forwards with more than 10 seconds of PK time per game - median defense in GVFHL: 60

Cole averaged 0:25 of SH TOI last season as a rookie. Getting any PK time at all as a rookie tells me there's a lot of defensive skill here. For reference, only 7 players from the 2021 draft played last season and only two saw more than 10 games - Sillinger (79) and Janis Moser (43).
The conventional wisdom with young players is that the offense comes long before the defense, and it can take years to earn the trust needed to play in key situations like the penalty kill. Sillinger is bucking that trend early in his career and earning Larsen's trust faster than anyone anticipated — even Larsen himself.
https://www.dispatch.com/story/sports/n ... 193511002/
Defensively, he finished 3rd among rookie forwards with 43 blocked shots and 13th among that same group of players with 24 takeaways.
https://www.1stohiobattery.com/columbus ... -sillinger
...and Sillinger led the Blue Jackets in individual scoring chances per 60 minutes at 5-on-5, per Natural Stat Trick. On top of that, he was lauded throughout the year for his effort and defensive knowledge, putting himself in the right spot to make plays in all three zones.
https://www.nhl.com/bluejackets/news/bl ... -335322606
...Sillinger’s straight-line speed is average at worst, and he is both deceptive and rapid with his directional changes in traffic, especially during zone entries. His balance is outstanding and helps him load up a hammer blow towards the net in spite of being draped by opposing pressure. If Sillinger’s skating was problematic, it didn’t impact his ability to generate a high volume of shots and torch defensemen and goalies in two premier junior circuits known for defense and goaltending.
https://www.thedraftanalyst.com/2021-nh ... sillinger/
Sillinger has good agility and edgework. He can make quick changes in direction and get away from defenders both with and without the puck.
His lateral agility and hands allow him to move laterally to open up shooting lanes. Sillinger is a smart player who can also take on the role of playmaker. His agility and hands also help him to open passing lanes.
https://lastwordonsports.com/hockey/202 ... ng-report/
Once he gets going, his straight-line speed is solid...
...his in-zone agility is excellent, and he’s shown improvement in technique year-over-year which is a testament to his work ethic.
https://www.secondcityhockey.com/2021/7 ... highlights
Blake-Habs
Montreal GM
Posts: 149
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 12:01 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by Blake-Habs »

Alrighty time is up for ratings, ratings committee going to do our magic now
2018 GVFHL Champs
2022 Eastern Conference Champs
Blake-Habs
Montreal GM
Posts: 149
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 12:01 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by Blake-Habs »

GVFHL Complated ratings challenges.xlsx
(15.25 KiB) Downloaded 1134 times
2018 GVFHL Champs
2022 Eastern Conference Champs
Blake-Habs
Montreal GM
Posts: 149
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 12:01 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by Blake-Habs »

Excuse the poor spelling of the file name, but ratings are given, thanks ratings commitee!
2018 GVFHL Champs
2022 Eastern Conference Champs
Ken - Ducks
Anaheim GM
Posts: 56
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 6:17 am

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by Ken - Ducks »

Just correcting that the last 4 players are Anaheim as long as you don't give them all to the Isles, no need to update spreadsheet :)
Blake-Habs
Montreal GM
Posts: 149
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2022 12:01 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by Blake-Habs »

Whoops my bad, they will be sent to the Montreal Canadiens
2018 GVFHL Champs
2022 Eastern Conference Champs
Pete
Vancouver GM
Posts: 62
Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2022 8:40 pm

Re: 2022-2023 Ratings Challenges- due September 25th

Post by Pete »

thanks to the RC
Post Reply